the Leafs, Islanders, and Oilers pulled off a three-team blockbuster that has the entire league buzzing. This deal shifts the balance of power in dramatic fashion and is already being labeled as one of the most polarizing trades in Lifetimepool history.
The Trade
Leafs Receive:
- Leon Draisaitl (F – EDM)
- Elias Pettersson (F – VAN)
- Lucas Raymond (F – DET)
- Jake Guentzel (F – TBL)
- Luke Hughes (D – NJD)
Owen Power (D – BUF)
- Josh Morrissey (D – WIN)
- Dustin Wolf (G – CGY)
- 2025 2nd Round Pick (via Islanders (Hitmen))
- 2026 4th Round Pick (Islanders)
Islanders Receive:
- Mitch Marner (F – LVK)
Ivan Demidov (F – MTL)
- Michael Misa (F – SJS)
- Jason Robertson (F – DAL)
Wyatt Johnston (F – DAL)
- Anton Frondell (R – CHI)
- Brandt Clarke (D – LAK)
- Bowen Byram (D – BUF)
- Tristan Jarry (G – PIT)
- Future Considerations (Player to be named by August 1st 2026)
- 2025 3rd Round Pick (via Leafs (Devils))
- 2026 5th Round Pick (Oilers)
Oilers Receive:
- 2026 3rd Round Pick (Leafs)
- Note: The players moving between the Leafs and Islanders never technically directly exchanged hands in prior deals. They were part of a three-way trade with the North Stars on January 5, 2025, which adds another wrinkle of complexity to this blockbuster. Though, the Oilers were added as additional insurance and to remain compliant to the Lifetimepool rules.
Note on Trade Details
Please be advised that the initial posting of this trade contained inaccuracies in the listed players. Following subsequent clarifications and adjustments between the parties, the trade has been finalized and is now accurately reflected. Any previous versions should be considered superseded by the current, corrected record.
Leafs Perspective: “Win-Now or Bust”
The Leafs swing for the fences, landing not one but two franchise superstars in Leon Draisaitl and Elias Pettersson. Add in Guentzel, Raymond, and a young goalie in Wolf, and this is a roster that now looks like an immediate contender for the top of the standings.
But this came at a heavy price—Robertson, Johnston, Demidov, and Misa were seen as cornerstone pieces for years to come. If this group doesn’t bring a championship soon, the Leafs could pay the price in future seasons.
Still, in the short term, the Leafs are the clear “winners” in terms of star power.
Islanders Perspective: Betting on the Future
This move is a massive shake-up for the Islanders. Out go Draisaitl, Pettersson, Power, and Hughes—players who defined their roster. In return, they add youth, prospects, and Robertson/Johnston, who can be franchise cornerstones for the next decade.
The Islanders essentially press reset, pivoting from being on the fringe of contention to focusing on long-term stability. Whether this works depends on the development of Demidov, Misa, and Frondell, along with Clarke’s growth on the back end.
It’s a gamble that could make them a powerhouse in 3–5 years but leaves their near-term competitiveness in question.
Oilers Perspective: The Facilitator
The Oilers only appear in this trade to make it legal under Lifetimepool rules—since the Leafs and Islanders had restrictions on direct swaps due to prior deals. In the end, Edmonton receives a 2026 3rd round pick from the Leafs, essentially acting as the broker to unlock the blockbuster.
While not flashy, but to provide extra insurance the Oilers add draft capital as they continue their rebuild.
Verdict: Winners and Losers
-
Winners: Leafs (short-term firepower and instant contender status)
-
Question Mark: Islanders (potential future juggernaut, but risk of collapse in the present)
-
Neutral: Oilers (pick up a free asset for being the middleman)
Final Thoughts
This trade will be debated for years. Was it reckless for the Islanders to sell off Draisaitl and Pettersson? Or brilliant, laying the foundation for a dynasty? Did the Leafs just buy their way into the Lifetimepool Cup?
One thing is certain: this deal has shaken the very fabric of the league and has everyone counting the days until next season.
